So, my homeys over at Movie Mobsters posted a very interesting question on Facebook last week. Here it is:
Is Inception the best movie of the year and Christopher Nolan’s best film?
My answer to this was “yes” and “no”.
Inception is by far the best film I’ve seen this year. Outside of
animated films, it’s not even a close race. However, is it Nolan’s best
work? I don’t think so. So, I’ve set out to do the near impossible and
rank Christopher Nolan’s short but impressive filmography. As you know,
Christopher Nolan was ranked #1 on my list of DIRECTORS THAT GET MY DOLLARS. The
only filmmakers that come close in quality in recent years, in my
opinion, again, are the fellas over there at Pixar. I love a challenging
list so let’s do it. Here they are (in order):
8. DOODLEBUG.
This film comes in at #8 for 2 reasons. 1) It’s a short film. 2) I haven’t seen it.
A fine little Black and White film and a great feature length debut but far from the calliber of Nolan’s other films.
6. IMSOMNIA.
Not even 2 big stars, Robin Williams and Al
Pacino at a time when they were turning out solid work, could save this
film. It’s shot nicely and I love the whole going crazy due to lack of
sleep (or as I call it: 1997 to 2003) but this film is not one of
Nolan’s best.
T-4. INCEPTION.
Definately a great film. Unfortunately, it’s one of Nolan’s and, in my opinion, is about as good as…
T-4. THE PRESTIGE.
This film is fantastic. I actuallly chose
it as one of my underrated films on MILFcast but had to cut it because
we ran long. I love this film and just feel like The Illusionist stole a
bit of it’s thunder and kept it from getting the recognition I think it
would have had if it had the chance to stand on it’s own.
3. THE DARK KNIGHT.
I’m not putting this 3rd for shock factor
but I also didn’t start a blog and podcast to sit and agree with
everyone. TDK is one of my favorite films… but if you take out the Heath
Ledger factor, it’s easily Nolan’s 2nd best Batman effort.
2. MEMENTO.
Memento and Inception are equally as
brilliant. However, I have to give Memento the edge for becoming popular
before Nolan himself and doing it on a shoestring budget by comparison.
This is Nolan’s best original idea and would be his best film had he
not made…
1. BATMAN BEGINS.
This is the gold standard for comic book
films and, in my opinion, the best entry into the sub-genre. The reason
it stands apart is because of how well Nolan was able to ground the
whole thing in a believable reality. Bruce Wayne’s motivation is
explored much deeper than in other incarnations, his weapons and their
inception (pun intended) becomes believable for reasons other than Wayne
is a billionaire and can buy anything he wants and he even manages to
make the Batmobile believable. Also features one of the greatest movie
posters (above) of all time. A GREAT overall film that not even Katie
Holmes could ruin and, again, in my opinion, Nolan’s best!
没有评论:
发表评论